Why I Am Not an Arminian
Why I Am Not an Arminian  -     By: Robert A. Peterson, Michael D. Williams
Buy Item $16.49 Retail: $23.00 Save 28% ($6.51)
In Stock
Quantity:
Stock No: WW832483
InterVarsity Press / 2004 / Paperback
Quantity:

Add To Cart

Paypal Buy Now
Add To Wishlist
eBook $12.89 View Details
Quantity:


Add To Cart

Paypal Buy Now
Wishlist

Why I Am Not an Arminian

InterVarsity Press / 2004 / Paperback

Buy 100 or more for $15.67 each.
In Stock
Stock No: WW832483


  • Other Formats (2)
Other Formats (2)
Description
Availability
Price
Add
Include
  1. In Stock
    $12.89
    Retail: $22.99
    Add To Cart
    0
    $12.89
  2. In Stock
    $16.49
    Retail: $23.00
    Add To Cart
    $16.49

Product Description

What's wrong with Arminianism? Arminian theology is sweeping through the evangelical churches of North America. While most Arminians are good, sincere, orthodox Christians, authors Roberts A. Peterson and Michael D. Williams contend that aspects of Arminian thought are troubling both biblically and theologically. In particular, they argue, Arminians have too lofty a view of human nature and an inadequate understanding of God's sovereign love in Christ. This book explores the biblical, theological and historical background to the Calvinist-Arminian debate. The irenic nature and keen insight of this book will be appreciated by laypeople, pastors and scholars alike.

Product Information

Title: Why I Am Not an Arminian
By: Robert A. Peterson, Michael D. Williams
Format: Paperback
Number of Pages: 224
Vendor: InterVarsity Press
Publication Date: 2004
Dimensions: 8.25 X 5.5 (inches)
Weight: 10 ounces
ISBN: 0830832483
ISBN-13: 9780830832484
Stock No: WW832483

Related Products

  1. Predestination & Free Will: Four Views of Divine Sovereignty & Human Freedom
    Add To Wishlist
    Predestination & Free Will: Four Views of Divine Sovereignty & Human Freedom
    David Basinger, Randall Basinger
    InterVarsity Press / 1986 / Trade Paperback
    $23.44 Retail: $25.00 Save 6% ($1.56)
    4 Stars Out Of 5 4 Reviews
  2. Chosen for Life: The Case for Divine Election
    Add To Wishlist
    Chosen for Life: The Case for Divine Election
    Sam Storms
    Crossway / 2007 / Trade Paperback
    $14.99 Retail: $21.99 Save 32% ($7.00)
    5 Stars Out Of 5 3 Reviews
  3. Chosen by God [R.C. Sproul]
    Add To Wishlist
    Chosen by God [R.C. Sproul]
    R.C. Sproul
    Tyndale House / 1994 / Trade Paperback
    $10.49 Retail: $15.99 Save 34% ($5.50)
    5 Stars Out Of 5 17 Reviews

Publisher's Description

What's wrong with Arminianism? Arminian theology is sweeping through the evangelical churches of North America. While most Arminians are good, sincere, orthodox Christians, authors Robert A. Peterson and Michael D. Williams contend that aspects of Arminian thought are troubling both biblically and theologically. In particular, they argue, Arminians have too lofty a view of human nature and an inadequate understanding of God's sovereign love in Christ. Why I Am Not an Arminian explores the biblical, theological and historical background to the Calvinist-Arminian debate. The irenic nature and keen insight of this book will be appreciated by laypeople, pastors and scholars alike.

Author Bio

Robert A. Peterson (Ph.D., Drew University) is professor of systematic theology at Covenant Theological Seminary in St. Louis, Missouri. He was formerly professor of New Testament and theology at Biblical Theological Seminary in Hatfield, Pennsylvania. His books include (all Presbyterian Reformed) and (coedited with Chris Morgan, Zondervan). He has written numerous articles, was a contributor to the second edition of the (Baker) and edits Covenant Seminary's journal,
Williams is professor of systematic theology at Covenant Theological Seminary in St. Louis, Missouri.

ChristianBookPreviews.com

In their book, Why I am not an Arminian, Peterson and Williams attempt to provide a defense of Dortian Calvinism by questioning the basic tenets of Arminian theology. Their study uses a two-pronged approach, sometimes discussing the controversy in the context of history, while at other times approaching the discussion on a topical basis.
The authors are aware of the pitfalls of writing a book with a polemical approach. They have seen, with concern, poorly written polemics on both sides of the Calvinist / Arminian debate. In their attempt to not repeat past errors, they do a passable job.
The book begins with a historical study of the early church controversy between Augustine and Pelagius. Calvinism, they argue, is grounded firmly in Augustine. Many have argued that Arminianism is Pelagianism reborn. Peterson and Williams argue that though there are similarities, reducing Arminianism to Pelagianism is an extreme oversimplification. In the end, they argue, Arminianism is similar to the semi-Augustinian view that prevailed at the Synod of Orange.
The book then moves to a discussion of the topics of predestination and perseverance. The approach of these chapters and those topical chapters that follow is the same. The Arminian view is stated, with supporting biblical texts. The authors then give a Calvinist exegesis of each of these texts and argue for their view. Occasionally representative Arminian or Calvinist theologians are used to illustrate a point.
In the next chapter, the authors give us an extended description of decretal theology as developed by Calvin, Beza, and others. They then move us into the Arminian debate that culminated at the Synod of Dort. This chapter is arguably the most revealing and marks a shift in the tone of the book.
The last three chapters (Inability, Grace, and Atonement) take an unapologetic and polemical view. The tone is decidedly less winsome than the chapters that precede it. And, in a way, they seem to reveal the true undercurrent of the book.
I would heartily recommend this book to an Arminian or a Calvinist, albeit for different reasons. Though unabashedly Calvinist, the authors do present Arminian views and arguments honestly and fairly, even to the extent that they give Arminian arguments against Calvinism. When presenting the counterview, the arguments often seem strangely assertive. They assert something to be true because a biblical text “says” it. However, when you finish the paragraph, you’re not sure the text really said what they think it did.
In essence, the book becomes a cogent criticism of both Arminianism and Calvinism, and for this reason, I do appreciate it in a limited way. The image of Arminianism in the book is of a theological approach that is extremely uncomfortable with the effects of sin while the image of Calvinism is one that seems uncomfortable with a loving God. Though many examples could be given, one for each will suffice. “It is hard to believe that 2 Peter 3:9 teaches that God wants the false teachers, whom he condemns in 2 Peter 2, to repent.” (p. 181) What? God doesn’t want sinners to repent? This reader is forced to wonder if he could love this Calvinist god. Arminianism doesn’t fair much better. “Ken Grider explains, ‘We can either accept Christ or reject Him–and our eternal destiny depends upon our free response to God’s offer of salvation.’” (p. 175) My salvation depends on my choice? How can my choice be certain? How, if not based in God’s action, is my salvation certain?
As I closed this book my thought was clear. “I’m glad I’m neither Arminian nor Calvinist.” Though it is not surprising, it is somewhat disappointing that the book seems to present all theology as a choice between Arminius and Calvin. This is just the sort of false dichotomy that the authors condemn elsewhere. You see, there are other options. Nevertheless, this is a book that either a Calvinist or an Arminian may find helpful. – Charles Lehmann, Christian Book Previews.com

Editorial Reviews

"A highly nuanced, theologically erudite work which presents Arminianism in the best possible light and then shifts the focus onto a positive construction of Calvinism to counter Arminian claims."
"Very beneficial to those learning about Calvinism or Calvinists who are looking to reinforce their particular perspective. . .Very useful as a supplemental text for one studying theology. Pastors who have an interest in theology will appreciate the brevity of the book."

Ask a Question

Find Related Products

Author/Artist Review

Back
×
Back
×

Ask a Question

What would you like to know about this product? Please enter your name, your email and your question regarding the product in the fields below, and we'll answer you in the next 24-48 hours.

If you need immediate assistance regarding this product or any other, please call 1-800-CHRISTIAN to speak directly with a customer service representative.