- All Products
- Accompaniment Tracks
- Bible Accessories
- Bible Covers
- Bible Studies & Curriculum
- Buy in Bulk
- Christian Living
- Church & Pastoral
- Church Supplies
- Clothing & Accessories
- Crafts & Recreation
- eBooks On Sale
- Gift & Home
- Last Chance Bargains
- New Release
- Slightly Imperfect
- Streaming Video
- Student & Teens
- Sunday School
Have questions about eBooks? Check out our eBook FAQs.
|Format: DRM Protected ePub|
Vendor: Thomas Nelson
Publication Date: 2008
The search of your life is the search for your life.
What you are holding right now is an exploration of the human spirit; a journey into our deepest longings, our desires, our needs, our cravings, our souls.
Our need for intimacy, meaning, and destiny point to the existence of God and our need to connect with Him. This book will deeply stir you to consider and chase after the spiritual implications of your souls' deepest longings.
Erwin R. McManus (BA, University of North Carolina; MDiv, Southwestern Baptist Theological Seminary) serves as lead pastor and cultural architect of Mosaic, a diverse, multi-ethnic church based in Los Angeles, California. As founder of Awaken, an entrepreneurial community, Erwin collaborates with a team of dreamers and innovators who specialize in the field of developing and unleashing personal and organizational creativity. A national and international consultant on culture, change, leadership, and creativity, he partners with Bethel Theological Seminary as a futurist and distinguished lecturer. He is the author of the ECPA Silver Medallion Award-winning book, An Unstoppable Force, and Seizing Your Divine Moment, Uprising: A Revolution of the Soul, and The Barbarian Way.
While I can appreciate his effort to speak to the lost and help them to see their need of Christ, there are a number of biblical problems with the book that concern me. In an effort to be fair, and provide McManus an opportunity to clarify several statements in his book, I sent an e-mail offering him an opportunity to clear these things up. His ministry sent me a link to a message he had given entitled "Soul Cravings: 08 Seek." This only helped to confirm that McManus does not fully understand the Gospel, but more than that, he is willing to proof-text the Bible in order to justify aberrant teaching. An example of this is an assumption he makes that serves as the main thrust of the book. He describes those who are not yet in a saving relationship with Christ as "seekers," a concept that is currently very popular within the evangelical church. This idea can be found on such pages as: 230, 231, 239, 254, and 283. One of the clearest pictures he gives of what a seeker is, appears on page 284: "[Yanni] was not a follower of Christ, but he was a very honest and sincere seeker." It is clear by the overall context of his book that he is describing those who are not yet in a saving relationship with God.
The main premise of his book is unsupportable by the Bible. Further, not only does the Bible not teach what he claims - that unbelievers are searching for God - it actually teaches the opposite.
While listening to his audio message referenced above, there were three passages he used to build his case that unbelievers seek God: Acts 17:27, Isaiah 55:6, and Luke 11:5-13. Space does not allow for a detailed exposition of each passage. Any reputable commentary can be consulted. As to Acts 17:27, contrary to how McManus uses it, it does not teach that unbelievers seek Him, that they want to, or that they even have the ability to do so. What Paul is explaining is that God has provided mankind with general revelation of Himself through His creation so that man can see that the world around him is made by God. This general revelation makes man responsible before God. Paul also teaches this in Romans 1:18-20. McManus has misused Acts 17:27, as he has Isaiah 55:6, which says nothing about the lost being able to seek God. Isaiah was describing what the Jews - people who were already in a covenant relationship with God - should do. At best, these passages show responsibility, not ability. As far as ability is concerned, one would need to look no further than Ephesians 2:1, where Paul describes the lost as thoroughly dead in their sin. Spiritually dead people have no ability to seek God. Likewise, he has misused Luke 11:5-13. The passage is not about unbelievers diligently seeking God, and through doing so will find Him, but about those who are already saved learning how to pray. Recommended commentaries that offer helpful explanations for these passages include Keil & Delitzsch (on Isaiah), and William Hendrickson (on Luke). As for Acts 17:27, this reviewer has found a good explanation in Louis Berkhof's Systematic Theology (1991 ed., p. 475).
Since a basic principle of Scripture interpretation is to compare Scripture with other Scripture, we would need to see what else the Bible says about unbelievers seeking God in order to have a well-rounded, biblical understanding. For that, we would need to consult Romans 3:11, where Paul clearly says, in part, "There is none who seeks for God." No more vivid image of man in his unsaved condition can be found than in this chapter. In saying the lost don't seek God, Paul borrowed that from David, who makes the same statement twice, once in Psalm 14:2, and again in Psalm 53:2, where he says in unambiguous language: "The Lord has looked down from heaven upon the sons of men, to see if there are any who understand, who seek God." What follows is most compelling, for David continues in verse 3 by explaining that God found no one. The Hebrew is very expressive on the fact that no one seeks God. Keil & Delitzsch have this to say: "The universality of corruption is expressed in as strong terms as possible . . . not a single one who might form an exception" (Commentary on the Psalms, p. 127). The Greek behind Paul's words in Romans 3:11 is just as explicit.
The very concept that the souls of men crave God could not be more unbiblical.
Another comment made in Soul Cravings that this reviewer found to be unbiblical was this one on page xvi: "Jesus once said that the Kingdom of God is within us" (Luke 17:21). A similar statement is made on page 285: "I am certain that if you will take the time to journey to the depths of your soul, you will not leave there disappointed, and perhaps to your surprise and astonishment what you will find there is God." McManus indicates at the bottom of page xviii that he is writing to an audience of unbelievers: "where you might meet God." And further, "I've never believed you can or should even try to force God on someone." The question I would have is: Where, in the entire Bible, does it say that unbelievers have God inside them? When McManus quotes Jesus' words from Luke 17:21 he has completely missed the Lord's intent. While there is some disagreement among commentators over whether Jesus said "the Kingdom of God is within us" (Hendriksen), or "the Kingdom of God is among us" (Pate), there is agreement among them that He would not have told the Pharisees to whom He was speaking that God was inside them. These were the Lord's bitter opponents! Telling unbelievers that God is inside them, and that if they seek hard enough for Him they will find Him inside, is a teaching that is not supported by any passage in the Bible. Rather, it comes from Eastern philosophy, and is a core teaching of Hinduism.
All in all, Soul Cravings has more theological/biblical problems than can be addressed in a short review such as this. This is not a book that should be given to the lost. The lack of a clear gospel presentation, the misrepresentation of important biblical passages, and a misunderstanding of what the Bible actually says about mans' condition before he is saved, and the author's willingness to proof-text the Bible, makes this work one that should be avoided at all costs. Ray Hammond, Christian Book Previews.com
Dr. Jennifer Morrow5 Stars Out Of 5March 8, 2008Dr. Jennifer MorrowThis book is a continual read for me. I have read many segments over and over just because they are so good. Soul Cravings really allowed me to understand the depth of God's desire for me to be in an intimate relationship with him. Not to just call on him when I need a prayer answered or a burden lifted -but to really let him into my thought processes. I don't think that the purpose of the book is to "hook" and unbeliever - but it is for the believer to understand that his/her soul craves to be near God and that God longs to have us crave him.I have used this book as a devotional for my staff and have gotten and great discussions have manifested.GREAT READ!
Rev. Todd Inman5 Stars Out Of 5July 5, 2007Rev. Todd InmanI have read a lot of books by Christians authors, but I have never read one with as much desire and passion to bring our hearts and minds to the deepest need for craving the ways and heart of God as much as Soul Cravings does. I have purchased this book for friends and family members. It is just one of those books that you highly recommend to those you love and care about to read.
Pastor-Teacher Gary E. Gilley2 Stars Out Of 5May 11, 2007Pastor-Teacher Gary E. GilleySoul Cravings is sort of an apologetic aimed at the postmodern generation. Rather than persuade his audience with biblical proofs, scientific evidence or logical arguments, McManus has chosen a philosophical approach. His reasoning is that our souls crave three things: intimacy, destiny and meaning. The fact that all human beings have these cravings is evidence for the existence of God.Rather than take the reader back to Scripture (which describes and points the true way to God) or to Jesus, who most fully explains Him (John 1:14, 18), McManus would have us look inside ourselves to find God. And while Romans 1 and 2 would agree that God has planted evidence of Himself within our souls, the Scriptures are equally clear that faith comes by hearing and hearing by the word of God (Romans 10:17). One of the problems with pointing people back to themselves to find God lies in the wickedness of our hearts (Jeremiah 17:9) and the inadequacy of our souls to comprehend God unaided by the Spirit using the Word. This is the fatal flaw in McManus system. At no point does he explain to his reader the gospel message. It is as if such information will get in the way. Rather, we follow our cravings and our cravings lead us to God. The Scriptures do not agree.In the end he succeeds in identifying the true longing of our heart (cravings) but fails to point us in the right direction. He does focus us on God, but it is the God found within our souls. He talks about Christ and the cross but reduces their meaning to nothing more than unconditional love. He does not explain mans great problem as being sin, and his solution found only in Christ. And he does not talk to us about repentance or faith. He has opened the door in Soul Cravings to explore the true God but he has not taken his reader beyond the threshold.
Find Related Products▼▲
- Christian Living >> Spirituality >> Spiritual Direction
- Christian Living >> Spirituality >> Spiritual Growth >> Christian Character & Purpose
- Download >> eBooks >> Christian Living >> Spirituality
- eBooks >> Christian Living >> Spirituality >> Spiritual Direction
- eBooks >> Christian Living >> Spirituality >> Spiritual Growth