Overall, this is a great product if you have two students working at the same level in Saxon Math. The only thing it is missing is the Meeting book, which comes with the Home School kit for the first student. I now need to order the meeting book separately before we can begin with this math class. I wish they would also include this in the set. I am new to Saxon Math, and so cannot comment on the content of this class.
I've been using Saxon Math for years with my other students. I have a first grade student who has high-functioning autism. I am confident no matter what the challenges may be, that my student will have a high math aptitude because of the quality and details Saxon puts into their curriculum. It's cumulative so while they are learning new lessons, they are constantly studying the older ones. Another aspect I like is the pages are not "busy" which helps against distractions and keep the student focused on the assignments.
Saxon math 1 is an excellent program you can easily tailor to your child's individual needs. Some of it IS repetitive but I find it enforces concepts sticking with your child later on. CBD is the best price around!
I love the early books for Saxon math because through a lot of repetition and building step by step, kids learn to master basic math that gives confidence and ability to add to a solid foundation as they go through school.