Brevard S. Childs
"Marvin Sweeney's learned monograph will shortly become a standard reference work for all future researchers of Isaiah 1–39. He offers exhaustive bibliographies, lucid background material for the current scholarly agenda, and a detailed structural analysis of each individual unit. . . Useful material for the continuing interpretive enterprise. "
H. G. M. Williamson
"Sweeney stands in the forefront of modern research on the book of Isaiah. This valuable commentary, which includes a comprehensive bibliographical survey of previous work as well as many stimulating new insights, is an indispensable resource to which scholars will want to return time and again in their continuing engagement with this central book of the Hebrew Bible."
Bibliotheca Sacra
"A welcome addition to this series, which has proved helpful in approaching the Old Testament as literature. . . The author has provided a reliable and practical access to the complexity of the Isaianic material, an entrée that will prove beneficial to pastors and scholars alike."
Internationale Zeitschriftenschau für Bibelwissenschaft und Grenzgebiete (IZBG)
"An ideal companion to all other existing commentaries with whom Sweeney engages in a constant and often lively dialogue. . . Highly recommended!"
Journal of the American Oriental Society
"Highly recommended."
Journal of the Evangelical Theological Society
"This volume, the ninth to appear in the series, is one of the best so far. . . The introduction is very well written and shows a keen grasp of the issues in form criticism, both past and present. . . Even for those who may disagree with Sweeney's views on compositional history, this is an invaluable tool for understanding the compositional strategy of the book of Isaiah. Sweeney's meticulous work is to be highly commended and will stand the test of time as a first-class exegetical tool."
Scripture Bulletin (U.K.)
"S. should be applauded for the quality of these and for this contribution to the long history of eminent commentaries on Isaiah. No serious study of Isaiah can take place without it."
The Bible Today
"An invaluable tool for teacher and student alike."
Ronald E. Clements
"Sweeney's book marks a major milestone in Isaiah studies. The close examinations of the forms of the prophecies of Isaiah 1–39 and the role that this primary collection has played in the structure and formation of the book of Isaiah as a whole are splendidly shown. . . This volume must surely become an indispensable starting point for the serious student, and I warmly recommend it."
Biblical Interpretation
"Sweeney has written a very important contribution, not only to Isaiah 1-39 but also to the formation of Isaiah 1-66. His work is certainly the most up to date commentary on Isaiah 1-39 and all readers of this text will be grateful for Sweeney's exhaustive bibliography on the subject. No one who is seriously engaged in the research of Isaiah can neglect Sweeney's work and his contribution will certainly stimulate further discussion."
