4.3 Stars Out Of 5
4.3 out of 5
(2)
(0)
(1)
(0)
(0)
Quality:
4.5 out Of 5
(4.5 out of 5)
Value:
4 out Of 5
(4 out of 5)
Meets Expectations:
3.5 out Of 5
(3.5 out of 5)
100%
of customers would recommend this product to a friend.
SORT BY:
SEE:
Displaying items 1-3 of 3
Page 1 of 1
  1. Pat
    5 Stars Out Of 5
    The Magna Carta of Humanity
    June 21, 2022
    Pat
    I read this as a nonAmerican. I do think everyone would be so enlightened as to how events at Mount Sinai have changed the relationship of ordinary citizens to their governments, how we ought to think about government and freedom! This book is revolutionary!
  2. Michael
    Indian Trail, NC
    Age: 55-65
    Gender: Male
    5 Stars Out Of 5
    Good Read On Human Freedom
    May 26, 2021
    Michael
    Indian Trail, NC
    Age: 55-65
    Gender: Male
    Quality: 5
    Value: 5
    Meets Expectations: 5
    "The Magna Carta Of Humantiy" by Os Guinnness is an excellent read on today's struggle for freedom in America. Guinness has written several thought-provoking titles in the past and this one is no different. The author uses the American Revolution and French Revolution as the basis for his points and compares and contrasts the revolutions and how they are relevant today.

    Things I liked about the title:

    - As mentioned earlier, a thought-provoking title like Guinness' other titles.

    - Well-written and points are clearly made, whether or not you agree with his conclusions.

    - Liked how he uses the example of the Jews in Egyptian bondage to show how various peoples, at various times, in various countries, have suffered in bondage.

    - Appreciate Guinness having the boldness to list several examples of America's inconsistency of being a land of freedom and yet having a long history of slavery (and not just in the South).

    - Various ways America can experience greater freedom (it starts with repentance for past and present sins).

    All in all, an excellent read and I look forward to reading again. I was given a review copy by IVP in exchange for a fair review and appreciate the opportunity.
  3. bookwomanjoan
    Oak Harbor, WA
    Age: Over 65
    Gender: Female
    3 Stars Out Of 5
    Too academic in style but does call for repentance of America's past and present sins
    May 23, 2021
    bookwomanjoan
    Oak Harbor, WA
    Age: Over 65
    Gender: Female
    Quality: 4
    Value: 3
    Meets Expectations: 2
    I have mixed feelings about this book. Because this is a book review and not a paper addressing all of the issues in the book, I will only consider the most important concerns I have about the book.

    America is in a crisis of freedom, Guinness says. I appreciate his exploration of the concept of freedom. True freedom is not the freedom to pursue all desires and passions. True freedom requires responsibility. True freedom is "the power to do what we ought..." (158) It requires virtue and self-limitation.

    Guinness presents "...the exodus as the precedent and pattern of Western freedom." (19) The fundamental principles of the Exodus Revolution should be recognized as the Magna Carta of humanity. One of those principles is that man is created in the image of God. "Each individual human is exceptional." (78) Evil, injustice and oppression "are always to be fought." (78) I agree.

    I have issue with one of his principles, however, that covenant people were equals before the law, in schooling and in worth. (94) Leviticus 27 is clear women were valued less than men. Women were not allowed education in that society. The true Sinai principle of the inequality of women bore fruit in America with women not being allowed to vote for over a century, nor be allowed to engage in higher education or even own property for decades after the nation's founding.

    Another problem I find with using Sinai in relation to the founding of America is the role of God. Only the power of God was able to free the Israelites. "Without the intervention of God, there would have been no exodus..." (138) Can Sinai be related to America? God founded a theocracy. The Israelites were given specific instructions for religious action and belief. America was founded on the principle that a religion could not be established by law, nearly opposite the situation at Sinai. The religious aspects of Exodus and 1776 are very different and I think Guinness' argument falls flat.

    Guinness defends the American experiment. He acknowledges the evil and hypocrisy of slavery but says if "acknowledged and corrected," the founding documents stand clear and strong. (22) I was disappointed Guinness failed to recognize and address the repeated slaughter and disenfranchisement of Native Americans. Near the end of this book, Guinness identifies the serious work needed to acknowledge and correct that evil associated with America's founding.

    Guinness is, in general, very critical of the progressive left. He does admit, however, that they have reason to be upset. "Many of the injustices and inequalities are genuine, and they require genuine resolution." (209) It is in how they respond he finds error. At times, his attacks on the left are almost humorous. He writes, "...the attitude of the left is clear: if elections go the wrong way and investigations and impeachments also fail, what is left but assassination?" (35) Ah, but then his draft of this book went to the publisher before the 2020 election and the actions of January 6, 2021. How ironic.

    Guinness' book is written in a scholarly fashion and is, perhaps, aimed at scholars rather than those who need to hear and heed his message. He quotes various scholars, historians and authors, people most Americans will not recognize nor care to hear about. He also makes reference to so many political movements and ideas, average Americans may become glassy eyed as they skim over sections of material. Guinness also relies heavily on the work of Rabbi Sacks, former chief rabbi of Great Britain, something evangelical Christians may find puzzling.

    I agree with Guinness' conclusion. "For Sinai (and Calvary) America must make amends, and the very real sins must be confessed with very real repentance. But if this happens, the American experiment in freedom may be given a second chance and can then go forward both wiser and more humbly." (233) Forgiveness is the next essential act to reconciliation and restoration. But, repentance must come first.

    I appreciate Guinness' honesty at the role of Christians in creating the current anti-Christian feelings. "All too often, Christian behavior has flatly contradicted Christian beliefs." (32) "Christians have betrayed their Lord, dishonored their faith and brought down attacks on their own heads..." (32) "Confession, the willingness to acknowledge our sins...is essential today." (33) Will Christians take the first step of repentance?

    All the evils of America, and Guinness admits to the evils from slavery to Vietnam, (basically the entire history of the nation), were egregiously evil. (234) But, he argues, they were contradictions to the ideals of America's founding. Those ideals "should be lifted high so that succeeding generations could aspire to achieve them more faithfully than their ancestors did..." (234)

    From my observations of recent activities in the U.S., I would say the ball is in the court of the political right. Will leaders, those in political and religious power, repent of the egregious evils against the Blacks, Native Americans, the disenfranchised, and seek forgiveness and to make amends? Will a visionary leader call for a national acknowledgment of the sins and failures of the past and present and call to recommit to the principles of America's founding? (244) I am waiting.

    I received a complimentary egalley of this book from the publisher. My comments are an independent and honest review.
Displaying items 1-3 of 3
Page 1 of 1