Since the 19th century, scholars have argued that the earliest stories in the
Old Testament were probably recorded during the reigns of David and Solomon.
Source critics have tended to isolate at least four sources that lie behind
the Pentateuch (J, E, D, P) and have ascribed descending dates to the
compositions of these sources. In a richly textured and revolutionary book,
Schniedewind argues that the stories traditionally thought to have been
written in the 10th and ninth centuries B.C.E. were most likely composed more
than 100 years later. Taking a detailed historical and literary approach, he
reminds us that early Israel was a largely oral culture, and that even during
the consolidation of the kingdom under David and Solomon, few scribes were
interested in chronicling the stories of a people. By the eighth century
B.C.E., however, during Hezekiah's reign (727-698 B.C.E.), the king's scribes
engaged in writing and editing historical narratives and collecting the
proverbs attributed to Solomon. The urbanization of Jerusalem provided the
social context that allowed the movement from a primarily oral culture to a
primarily literary one. Thus, Schniedewind contends that the historical
narratives of Joshua, Judges, Samuel and Kings, in addition to the Pentateuch
and some of the prophetic writings, can be dated to Hezekiah's reign rather
than to an earlier Solomonic period or to a post-exilic Persian period.
Schniedewind's provocative thesis will likely generate some controversy, but
it will be well received among those who accept the historical revisionism of
Israel Finkelstein and others. (Apr. 6) Copyright 2004 Reed Business
Information.
