Between Pain & Grace: A Biblical Theology of Suffering
Between Pain & Grace: A Biblical Theology of Suffering  -     By: Gerald Peterman, Andrew Schmutzer
Buy Item $10.19 Retail: $22.99 Save 56% ($12.80)
In Stock
Stock No: WW409671
Moody Publishers / 2014 / Paperback

Add To Cart

Paypal Buy Now
Add To Wishlist
eBook $9.99 View Details

Add To Cart

Paypal Buy Now

Between Pain & Grace: A Biblical Theology of Suffering

Moody Publishers / 2014 / Paperback

In Stock
Stock No: WW409671

  • Other Formats (2)
Other Formats (2)
  1. This product will be released on 04/28/18.
    Retail: $17.99
    Add To Cart
  2. In Stock
    Retail: $22.99
    Add To Cart

Product Description

* How does God involve himself in our suffering? What part does Satan play in mental illness, sexual abuse, and betrayal? For millennia, believers have wrestled with the question of pain, yet have found few satisfying answers. Examining various attitudes in light of Scripture, Peterman and Schmutzer's thorough study sheds light on God's working in our lives. 320 pages, softcover from Moody.

Product Information

Format: Paperback
Number of Pages: 320
Vendor: Moody Publishers
Publication Date: 2014
Dimensions: 8.5 X 5.5 X .78 (inches)
ISBN: 0802409679
ISBN-13: 9780802409676

Publisher's Description

Why is there suffering? When will it end? Where is God in it?

Despite how common suffering is, we still struggle to understand it, and even more to bear through it. Between Pain and Grace gets to the heart of this struggle. Its honest and detailed portrait of life challenges our assumptions about pain, emotion, and God himself.

Born from a popular college course on suffering, this book answers critical questions like:  

  • Is God personally involved in our pain and suffering?
  • How should Christians handle emotions like grief and anger?
  • What does the Bible say about issues like mental illness, sexual abuse, and family betrayal?

Striking an elegant balance between being scholarly and pastoral, Between Pain and Grace is useful in the classroom, churches, and for personal reading. The authors draw from Scripture, personal experience, and even psychological research to offer a well-rounded and trustworthy take on suffering. 

Between Pain and Grace will give you confidence in God’s sovereignty, comfort in His presence, and wisdom for life this side of paradise. It will also make you more tender and better prepared to respond to the suffering of others. Read it today for a richer, more realistic relationship with God.

Author Bio

GERALD PETERMAN is Professor of Bible and Director of Biblical and Theological Studies at Moody Bible Institute. Before coming to Moody he taught at Palm Beach Atlantic College in West Palm Beach, FL, spent 4 1/2 years doing church planting for the Evangelical Free Church in central Florida and in south central Iowa, and also served eight years in the Air National Guard as a Chaplain. Peterman also serves part-time at his local church. For Moody Publishers he has written Joy and Tears: The Emotional Life of the Christian (2013) and Between Pain and Grace: A Biblical Theology of Suffering with Dr. Andrew Schmutzer. Research interests include New Testament Greek Language and Exegesis, Greek and Roman Background to the New Testament, and Biblical Theology. Gerald has been married to Marjory since January 1984, with two adult daughters, Bethany and Grace.

ANDREW SCHMUTZER (PhD, Trinity International University) is Professor of Biblical Studies at Moody Bible Institute (Chicago, Illinois). In addition to numerous articles and essays on the Old Testament, he has written the exegetical theology Be Fruitful and Multiply and two forthcoming commentaries on Ruth and Esther.

Editorial Reviews

"Peterman and Schmutzer’s, 'Between Pain and Grace: A Biblical Theology of Suffering,' is one of the best books that I have read on the topic, in a very long time. I must admit, I was skeptical at first. I thought, 'Oh boy, a book on theodicy coming from Moody, which is probably by a bunch of conservative theologians who are going to spout off their refashioned old-timer, Calvinistic readings of scripture,' but boy was I naïve, and flat out wrong. I found Peterman and Schmutzer’s book fresh, inspiring, challenging, and deeply biblical. They did their homework and are very well-read on the different theological and philosophical views on the topic, and incorporate other’s views throughout. Obviously, questions will still remain regarding the intricate dance between God, suffering, and evil, but I firmly believe many questions will be answered with compassion and wisdom. The reader’s faith, in an immanent, embodied, relational, emotional, sovereign, and loving God, in the midst of pain and suffering, will no doubt be strengthened. I recommend this book to Christians and skeptics alike."

Reviewed by Mark Karris on NetGalley, Feb 28, 2016

"Between Pain and Grace: A Biblical Theology of Suffering by Gerald W. Peterman, Andrew J. Schmutzer answers questions according to the Bible and what God has to say about this subject. When I first started this book I wasn't sure I was going to like it but what an eye-opener it is!

I was very interested in reading this, as I watched my Mother who was dying with cancer, as she suffered and the pain she endured. And as for myself I have suffered many things throughout my lifetime. I am now living with chronic pain. So yes you might understand why this is a book I would be quite interested in.

The authors take us on a journey through the Bible to show us how God is in pain himself. How it must break the heart of God to see how the people he has created behave so badly toward each other and destroy the earth he made for us to enjoy. Let's not forget how Jesus suffered for ALL of us, so that we can one day make Heaven our home. Who are we to expect any less suffering or pain than our Father in Heaven and our Savior?"

Reviewed by Kimberly Scott on NetGalley, Mar 18, 2016

Product Reviews

3.7 Stars Out Of 5
3.7 out of 5
3 out Of 5
(3 out of 5)
2.5 out Of 5
(2.5 out of 5)
Meets Expectations:
2.8 out Of 5
(2.8 out of 5)
of customers would recommend this product to a friend.
Displaying items 1-5 of 6
Page 1 of 2 12 Next
  1. Grant Murdock
    3 Stars Out Of 5
    Unless You're an Intellectual, Read a Different Book on Suffering
    December 5, 2016
    Grant Murdock
    Quality: 0
    Value: 0
    Meets Expectations: 2
    Suffering is an experience that far too many of us know far too well. We live in a world that is broken and in need of redemption. Gerald W. Peterman and Andrew J. Schmutzer, in their book Between Pain & Grace, attempt to help Christians wrestle with what the Bible has to say about our pain.

    The authors make a strong distinction between pain and suffering, early on in the book. Their claim is that pain is something everyone experiences, and that suffering is as well, but that suffering is fundamentally different than pain. The two concepts are fundamentally different to these men. Pain is an objective reality that we all experience, whereas suffering is a more subjective perception and response to the pain in our lives.

    Peterman and Schmutzer attempt to point out something important with their distinctions between pain and suffering; that is the fact that human beings do not have to respond to pain in the same way. We are able to respond differently than others to the pain we experience, especially those of us who know Jesus Christ, the God who became a Man and suffered for us.

    I would caution the reader to think critically of their distinction, however, as it seems that it may be a bit arbitrary to me. Suffering is not simply a subjective way of perceiving and responding to the pain in our lives. It is more than that, and I would argue that it is something that all of us experience at some point or another, regardless of how much faith or positivity we have. It is possible for Christians to suffer, and still worship God in the midst of their suffering with a kind of joy that transcends terrible circumstances.

    One would be hard pressed to legitimately argue that Jesus did not suffer on the cross, or that Paul and other apostles did not suffer during their ministries. Yet, both Jesus and the apostles approach suffering with a kind of joy in the midst of it, because of the God who is redeeming His people and His creation and the calling they've received. Jesus and the apostles loved those they ministered to, and their perception of their pain did not eliminate our ability to legitimately call it suffering.

    The authors hope to point out an important reality: Christians can respond differently to pain because of their identity in Christ. And to this I would add a hearty Amen! But, the authors go too far in their distinction between pain and suffering early on in the work, and I fear that it could minimize the experience of Jesus, the apostles, and even those who find themselves full of faith, yet suffering today. Their point that Christians have a unique hope in the midst of pain, however, is solid and incredibly true.

    A real strength of the book is the topics the authors attempt to cover in such a short volume. One can read about everything from how to think about pain and suffering, to Jesus' pain, and even the terrible experiences that some have in our world as they walk through horrific things such as sexual abuse, family difficulties, and even mental illness (which I would carefully define and qualify as a term that can only legitimately refer to actual diseases or deficiencies in the physical aspects of our bodies and brains that lead to all sorts of difficulty and pain, though I am not sure the authors would share my perspective and they may include more in their definition).

    However, the book's strengths will not have opportunity to overcome it's weaknesses for most readers, I fear. The authors write in such a way as to make it obvious that they are academics. It was surprising to me to read a work published by Moody that seemed so geared towards intellectuals and academics in the way it was written. When I received the work, I expected it to be a treatment of what the Bible had to say about suffering geared towards the average reader. It did not turn out to be so. I had hoped the work would be a helpful book to point people to who were in the midst of much pain themselves, but the academic type treatment of suffering here will benefit such an individual only minimally at best.

    However, for the reader who wants to think deeply about suffering from an intellectual standpoint, the book may we worth the read! I would not recommend it if it is one of the only books you will read on this topic, however. If you will only read one book on suffering, let it not be this one, but if you intend to read widely on the subject and think deeply, pick up a copy, as it could only help you consider a difficult topic more deeply.

    I received a copy of this book from the publisher (Moody) for the purpose of this

    review, as a part of their blogger review program. The thoughts here are my own honest opinions of the work, and I am grateful for the opportunity to review it as a part of Moody's program!
  2. contemplativereflections
    4 Stars Out Of 5
    Book Review: Between Pain & Grace
    September 15, 2016
    Quality: 0
    Value: 0
    Meets Expectations: 0
    In "Between Pain & Grace", Gerald Peterman and Andrew Schmutzer hope to encourage readers to develop a biblical theology that informs their understanding of pain and suffering. In examining different biblical examples of suffering including Job, Joseph and Jesus, the authors make helpful observations on how pain is an unavoidable part of our lives. However, suffering does not define our lives as our identity is found in Christ, the God-man who has experienced more suffering than any human being could ever bear. Besides analyzing biblical narratives, the book also discusses several different aspects of pain and suffering that often tear apart both the individual and the immediate community including sexual abuse, family tensions, and mental illness in an honest and practical manner. In each of the chapters, the authors seek to help readers understand the complexity of pain and how it permeates both individual and community life on many different levels. Furthermore, Peterman and Schmutzer bring out the message that though the brokenness of fallen creation and humanity is immensely deep, God is the One who most intimately knows our pain in the person and work of Jesus Christ. The book offers no easy solutions but point to Jesus as the One who can sympathize with us when we feel despair and disappointment. This does not mean that we simply sit there and bemoan the hardships and calamities we experience. Rather, the authors state that Christians are to actively prevent future suffering to the best of our ability while also engaging in lament and comfort those who are presently suffering. Peterman and Schmutzer repeatedly urge readers to go beyond mere patchwork solutions but to realize that pain and suffering runs deep in the human experience and often takes a slow and gradual process of healing which is found ultimately in Christ.

    One part of the book that I wrestled with is the discussion on the immutability and impassibility of God. The authors argue against the classical understanding of divine immutability and impassibility as removing all emotion from God. The authors point out several biblical passages that describe God as being angered or hurt as not merely anthropomorphisms but as actual descriptions of God's experience. On one hand, I find it helpful that the authors remind us from biblical examples that God is not uninvolved and void of emotion. However, the authors also seem to suggest that God reacts as humans do when encountering disturbing events which may imply that God changes through the interactions between Him and His creatures. I mention this not necessarily as a critique to the authors as I am a novice on the topic and assume the authors did not have the opportunity to fully explain their perspectives within the one chapter committed to the subject. I do however encourage readers to engage more deeply in understanding the subjects of divine immutability and impassibility as the implications are significant in terms of how we view God's involvement in pain and suffering.

    I would recommend this book to all who hope for a biblical understanding of the complexity of pain and suffering. The book strikes a good balance between academic and leisure reading allowing a wide audience to benefit from the material presented. The authors remind us that Jesus has conquered all including pain, sin, and death. While we groan under the heavy burdens in life, we fix our eyes firmly on our risen King who will one day return and set everything right. However, this does not imply that our present sufferings are meaningless as the pain we experience causes us to grow in spiritual maturity and greater dependence on Christ. God is not distant and aloof but is intimately involved in our lives and understand pain through His Son who took on flesh and became our sympathetic High Priest. Suffering and pain will never be eradicated in this present age but as children of God we yearn and look forward to the eternal bliss in the age to come.

    In compliance with Federal Trade Commission guidelines, I received a review copy from Moody Press in exchange for a book review.
  3. Michele Morin
    Warren, Maine
    Age: 45-54
    Gender: female
    5 Stars Out Of 5
    Pain, Emotion, and God
    September 1, 2016
    Michele Morin
    Warren, Maine
    Age: 45-54
    Gender: female
    Quality: 5
    Value: 5
    Meets Expectations: 5
    Elisabeth Elliot coined the most memorable definition of human suffering that I have ever heard: Suffering is wanting what you dont have or having what you dont want. These words came to mind often as I read Between Pain and Grace, because Gerald W. Peterman and Andrew J. Schmutzer have initiated a fresh conversation which does not claim to be the last word on suffering, but is characterized by the scope, depth, and fidelity one would expect from two of Moody Bible Institutes theology professors.

    My attention was arrested immediately by the authors careful distinction between pain and suffering. Consider this:

    Pain primarily objective, external, and typically social or physical as opposed to personal and mental.

    Suffering primarily subjective, internal, and typically mental or emotional.

    This distinction is important because not all pain is received as suffering just ask an Olympic gymnast or a brand-new mum. Conversely, those with leprosy or diabetic neuropathy would welcome pain as a means to alleviate the suffering that occurs when they injure their insensitive extremities. Dr. Eric Cassell chimes in with the succinct conclusion that the only way to learn whether suffering is present is to ask the sufferer.

    A biblical theology of suffering must include the truth that Scripture provides a voice for those who suffer; it acknowledges the reality of innocent suffering; and, without moralizing, it affirms the presence of God in the midst of pain. I never tire of hearing the truth that God is fluent in the language of lament. He has graciously appointed script writers in the psalms and prophets, and throughout Scripture, honest expressions of grief are portrayed as a natural exhale of worship.

    Because a lively faith is open to the uncomfortable questions and painful stories of those who suffer, the church gathered must be clear in its identity as a safe place for the expression of grief and disappointment. Counselors, individuals dealing with dysfunctional families, and those who have experienced sexual abuse or who are dealing in some way with mental illness will appreciate the authors frank discussion of these topics as they relate to what the Scripture says about pain and suffering.

    The term relational ecosystem runs as a theme throughout Between Pain and Grace, affirming the fact that there is no such thing as a private or contained sin. The relational ecosystem of Gods creation has been shaken to its roots by sin, and this is seen at every level:

    God with mankind;

    man with woman;

    humanity with animals;

    and humanity with the ground.

    Brokenness abounds and the outcome is alienation. Anger sends out generational shock waves that are amply illustrated in Old Testament family dysfunction. Peterman and Schmutzer refer to Davids family life as a relational debris field, acknowledging that we all are part of interlocking relationships that surround us like the rings of a tree.

    Our relational ecosystem, tangled as it is in personal weakness and sin (another fascinating distinction that the authors delineate), demonstrates the efficacy of the redemption that comes to us in the midst of our brokenness. Because God Himself chose a path of vulnerability for His Son, the record of Scripture is that God experiences pain and a theology of a suffering God is evident throughout the testimony of Scripture. Gods transcendence is balanced by His immanence, as evidenced in His compassionate love, His relatedness with His creation, and His willingness to risk relationally.

    Looking at The Lords Prayer through the lens of pain gives it a fresh application, for in Matthew 6, Jesus provides a model for prayer in a suffering world, a challenge to transcend our worries and pain by focusing first on Gods honor, Gods good, and Gods moral requirements.

    Opening ones life to spiritual leadership roles also opens the door to some unique forms of suffering rejection, hopelessness, and discontentment. We follow a Savior who entered into suffering voluntarily. Peterman and Schmutzer assert that leaders have likewise made that choice, but then offer the encouragement that tears shed are part of the leaders path to Christ-likeness.

    Since suffering is unavoidable on a fallen planet, this question is also unavoidable for the thinking believer: What needs to happen in the space between pain and grace? For most people (including the Apostle Paul!), it holds a journey of acceptance, a yielding of expectations, and most important of all, a commitment to receive the gift of suffering from the hand of an all-wise and sovereign God.


    This book was provided by Moody Publishers in exchange for my review. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commissions 16 CFR, Part 255 : Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising.
  4. JJ
    1 Stars Out Of 5
    Substandard and Pretentious.... Authors have little real pathos for suffering
    July 12, 2016
    Quality: 4
    Value: 1
    Meets Expectations: 1
    I am deeply disappointed with this book. It provides a sophomoric treatment of suffering written from the perspective of someone who knows nothing of the existential pathos and tribulation that is bound up with the heart of faith. I do not recommend this book.
  5. bookwomanjoan
    Oak Harbor, WA
    Age: Over 65
    Gender: Female
    4 Stars Out Of 5
    Good for church leaders and counselors
    June 14, 2016
    Oak Harbor, WA
    Age: Over 65
    Gender: Female
    Quality: 4
    Value: 4
    Meets Expectations: 4
    The authors have provided a biblical theology of suffering for pastors, ministry leaders, counselors, and others in church leadership. It is aimed at understanding our suffering based on biblical texts. It centers on what the Bible says about suffering well and helping others in their suffering.

    There are some thought provoking issues in this book. The one that struck me with the most force is our lack of lament. There is no place for lament in our church services, even though a good percentage of those in the pews are suffering. The authors draw attention to our dis-ease with engaging suffering in corporate worship. Expressions of pain and suffering are not welcome in church. We wear facades instead. This section of the book made me wonder how the church can engage misery and give voice to those suffering.

    Another issue is the suffering of God. The authors investigate that concept and how an understanding of the suffering of God helps those who have known pain. I found their discussion of fear was interesting too, especially whether it is always a sin. We are reminded of Jesus' experience of fear in the garden. There is also a discussion of the role of anger and how it can be redemptive. An exploration of forgiveness is included too.

    An insightful topic for me was the difference between pain and suffering. Pain is external and objective. It is a thing. Suffering is internal and subjective. It is an experience. Their discussion about the relationship of suffering to desires, goals, and sin was very enlightening.

    This is a good book for pastors, counselors, and others who want to help people live through suffering with grace, maturity, patience, insight, and proper action. The authors have included great chapters on the dysfunctional family, sexual abuse and mental illness. It is rather academic in style (for example, writing about the relational ecosystem in Genesis). Lay people may find it a bit too academic. There are questions included at the end of each chapter so the book could be used as a study by a church or counseling staff.

    I was raised in a denomination that was rather stoic. This book really helped me understand the necessity of giving voice to suffering. Silencing the voice only intensifies the suffering. I recommend this book to leaders, hoping others will also gain a glimpse of the importance of giving voice to the suffering. It is not a book to give to those in the midst of suffering, however.

    I received a complimentary egalley of this book from the publisher for the purpose of an independent and honest review.
Displaying items 1-5 of 6
Page 1 of 2 12 Next

Ask a Question

Find Related Products

Author/Artist Review


Ask a Question

What would you like to know about this product? Please enter your name, your email and your question regarding the product in the fields below, and we'll answer you in the next 24-48 hours.

If you need immediate assistance regarding this product or any other, please call 1-800-CHRISTIAN to speak directly with a customer service representative.