Nathan and Judi have moved on. Politician Nathan Whithorne's wife died two years ago, drowned in the Susquehanna River. Nathan has tried to move on with his life. He's even engaged to remarry. But Judi's body was never found, and when Nathan discovers that her ruby broach is missing, he suspects she's still alive. Judi Rydell is living a secret life on Bay Island, a small community on Lake Erie. She faked her death after receiving threatening notes, and she is sure Nathan is happier now that she is gone. He can continue his political career, and she can finally build the life she wants. When Nathan arrives on the island, Judi fears the worst. How did he find her, and what could he possibly want from her now? Nathan and Judi must confront the past and their relationship as they struggle to trust God to work out the details. But can they trust each other?