Opening John's Gospel and Epistles: Pastoral Reflections on Love, Light, and Logos (revised)
blend of scholarly material with pastoral insight
Teaching and preaching the New Testament text with vitality and faithfulness is a high calling. The tools for the faithful student of the New Testament are many and varied. A teacher's needs will be different than those being taught however, and many times a commentary is designed more for the end audience than for the one teaching them. Some resources delve too deeply into biblical languages and critical analysis - much deeper than the average teacher needs. Others package up the application so nicely that there is no effort expected or required of the reader.
Philip W. Comfort and Wendell C. Hawley have given us a unique blend of particularly helpful scholarly material and pastoral insight. In "Opening John's Gospel and Epistles" one finds detailed textual and interpretive notes, sprinkled throughout a warm exultation of the main points being taught in the text. The result is a manual or guide for the active teacher, rather than an application book or a detailed exegetical analysis.
The book is laid out in a helpful format, with 6-12 page introductions to the books (2 & 3 John are treated together), followed by separate discussions of each unit of text. The discussions include an exposition and notes on pretty much each verse. The section on John also includes a key words and phrases section.
The expositions set the stage and serve to provide a big picture and background for one's study and preparation. This is the place helpful application points and themes are raised. The notes explain the text and cover critical or textual matters in some detail (but those discussions stay brief and accessible).
Given Comfort's expertise in textual critical matters, the work abounds with detailed textual notes explaining alternate readings and the manuscript evidence behind various readings. This can be a strong point, as when the publication and canonicity of the Gospel and epistles are explained, and when the leading papyrii witnesses to John's writings are described. It can also be distracting to those less familiar or concerned about such matters. I think Comfort aims to make the wider church more aware of such discussions, and this work will make such points more accessible for sure. Of particular note, is the decision to set off the story of the woman caught in adultery (7:53-8:11) as an appendix to the section on John. The manuscript evidence argues against the inclusion of the story in the text of John's Gospel, and Comfort and Hawley correspondingly treat the passage as less than fully inspired.
The commentary reflects a conservative evangelical approach to Scripture. Detailed theological points of controversy are generally avoided, however, in favor of the explication of the text. In John 6, for instance, the transubstantiation debate and the unconditional election question (6:44), are only referenced obliquely. In John 3:5 the various interpretations for "born of water and of the Spirit" are offered, and the preferred choice defended briefly. That discussion was quite helpful, and the discussion stayed very irenic.
I found the claim that John's version of the Last Supper was not a Passover meal to be somewhat confusing. The introduction and also the discussion in chapter 19 assert that John asserted the Last Supper to be prior to the Passover meal. But the discussion in chapter 13 was referenced for more information, and there the commentary explained the Last Supper likely was a Passover meal.
The combination of two separate works into one presented some problems. Opening the Gospel of John was the original title. The work on the epistles was published as a separate work later in the Cornerstone Biblical Commentary series. Bringing the two works together is great, but I would have liked to see a greater attempt at standardizing the work as a whole. The Cornerstone Biblical Commentary Greek numbering system was used in the epistles of John for instance. Each Greek word is transliterated (as in the Gospel section), but it is a Strong's number, as well as another number as well. This convention is not followed in the Gospel of John. What makes this even more confusing, is there is no mention of what the numbering system is or means in this book at all. I had to pick up a Cornerstone commentary to find that the numbers with a prefix "TG" refer to a Tyndale's modified Strong's Greek number, and "ZG" refers to a similar numbering system popularized by Zondervan. "TH" and "ZH" refer to the numbers for the Hebrew words in such a system. A similar matter is the absence of end notes in the epistles of John entirely, whereas every section of the book of John had several end notes. Also the NLT is emphasized in the work covering the epistles whereas the section on John (produced before the publication of the NLT Bible) ignores it.
Along these lines, I encountered a few editing errors. Following the appendix to the Gospel of John, a list of three papyrii is found with no explanation as to why it is there. At the very end of the book a list is given of all the papyrii and major manuscripts and there are a few obvious typos in that list as well. Furthermore in at least two places (pg. 335 and 351) a single Greek word is followed by a reference to a Greek and a Hebrew number (TG & ZH).
These minor quibbles aside, the notes and commentary provided in this work seem especially clear, straightforward and eminently helpful. It will be a volume that I'll be keeping in arm's reach, whenever I teach from John's Gospel or his epistles. I recommend this book highly.
Disclaimer: This book was provided by Tyndale House Publishers for review. I was under no obligation to offer a favorable review.
May 28, 2011
A new kind of approach to Bible commentary, Opening Johns Gospel is a mixture of historical background, textual analysis and commentary. The authors, Philip W. Comfort and Wendell C. Hawley, break each chapter down verse by verse, so the book can also be used as a valuable resource for a devotional time or preparing a lesson on the Book of John or the epistles.After meeting once a week for six years and seeking Gods heart while writing, the authors created an excellent resource for teachers, pastors and laypeople that will be referred to again and again. Including the Gospel of John and the three epistles, the commentary gives a full insight into John and His relationship with Christ. A careful and indepth analysis of symbolism is the highlight of this book.I highly recommend it to anyone looking for a study of John and, in particular, teachers who may be leading a study on his writings. Disclosure of Material Connection: I received this book free from Tyndale House Publishers, Inc., as part of their Book Review Blogger Program. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions I have expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commissions 16 CFR, Part 255: Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising.
June 16, 2010
I received a free copy of this book from Tyndale House Publishers for review purposes, and so far I am impressed.The book takes you verse by verse through the Gospel of John, as well as the three letters of John. Not only does it give verse by verse explanations about what is goin on, but it seperates each section into a "snapshot" of Jesus, and gives an exposition of that aspect. I am finding it useful for preparing detailed Bible Studies on the Gospel, and signs, and foresee using it quite heavily in future for sermon preparation.The exposition strikes a useful balance between theological interpretation, and historical context. - A rare mix I think.I would highly recommend this for anyone interested in pulling John's writings apart, and moderate to serious scholars.
June 14, 2010