I am happy with this handwriting practice book. I have my son do one page a day as part of his homeschooling work. It gives enough practice to see improvement, but not so much that it has become a burden.
It is so true that you have to find what "fits" for your child. What works for one may not for another. That is the case with my 3rd Grader. We tried HWWT, and it produced tears for her! I let her review other curriculum/workbooks and she chose ARFH and LOVES it! She now asks to do her handwriting and is often the FIRST thing she does in our homeschool!