Compelling Interest: The Real Story Behind Roe v. Wade - unabridged audiobook on CD
- Media Type▼▲
- Author / Artist▼▲
- Top Rated▼▲
|Format: Compact disc|
Number of Pages: 256
Vendor: Roger Resler
Publication Date: 2012
Availability: In Stock
"This is a must read for anyone, whether you consider yourself pro-life or pro-choice. We must be prepared with factual information, which is what this book gives you. The abortion lobby has fooled the American public far too long. We need to know the truth about abortion and how these laws came to be. Read this book to get the truth." - Abby Johnson, Author, Unplanned, Former Health Center Director, Planned Parenthood
Mathaytes blogspotMichiganAge: 35-44Gender: male5 Stars Out Of 5Compelling & InterestingFebruary 4, 2013Mathaytes blogspotMichiganAge: 35-44Gender: maleQuality: 5Value: 5Meets Expectations: 5In the past 40 years, there have been many attempts from both sides of the abortion debate to frame the historical narrative to their advantage. Frequently, these attempts fail to address the fundamental issues involved because they do not take the time to understand the perspective of the other side. In his book, Compelling Interest: The Real Story Behind Roe vs. Wade, Roger Resler does the homework and offers a cogent analysis of the basic assumptions upon which the pro-abortion movement is based. Resler's analysis is relentlessly logical and he attacks the key philosophical underpinnings of the movement rather than wasting time knocking down straw men. Resler is unashamedly arguing from a pro-life position but his characterizations of the "pro-choice" position are well supported by direct quotations from leaders within the movement. He has clearly made an effort to understand the other side and that makes his critique much more powerful.
I liked several things about the book. First, and most importantly, Resler calls attention to the fact that fundamentally the abortion debate is a civil rights issue. The crux of the issue is whether it is appropriate for our legal system to define living human beings as "non-persons" and therefore deny to them rights and protections under the law. As Resler points out, the question of when human beings become full "persons" is a metaphysical rather than a scientific question. There is no biological question that a genetically unique human begins life at conception. The question is whether this human life should legally be considered a "person". Resler, like some others before him, highlights the fact that this is a debate about worldview issues rather than facts. From a legal standpoint, it is a debate about whether all humans possess unalienable rights that must be protected or if utilitarian value determines ones standing before the law.
Resler's analysis of the evolution of the semantics of abortion debate was also well done and valuable. I listened to the audiobook and was appreciative that the author narrated it. The reading was well done and quotations were often direct recordings of those quoted. Even when they were not, different voices were used which helped me follow the arguments and to keep my attention engaged. I especially appreciated the audio from the oral arguments before the court.
Other reviewers have mentioned that Resler is fond of overstatement and that the book gets redundant at times. There is a tendency toward dramatic emphasis but it simply reinforces the author's passion for the subject and is not too distracting. The organization of the work and Resler's desire to address each section thoroughly lends itself to a certain amount of repetition but the value is that each argument is essentially a contained unit increasing the usefulness of the book as a reference work. Resler is not the first person to make the arguments included in the book but his grasp of the material is outstanding and this book will be a helpful resource to those who are looking for a single volume that covers the range of issues involved. I recommend the book to anyone who wants to learn more about Roe vs. Wade or the abortion debate in general.
Other Customers Also Purchased
Little House on the Prairie: Christmas Double Feature, DVDLionsgate Home Entertainment / DVD$11.99 Retail:5 Stars Out Of 5 6 Reviews
$14.99Save 20% ($3.00)Availability: In StockCBD Stock No: WW312597
25 Ways to Win with People: How to Make Others Feel Like a Million Bucks - unabridged audiobook on CDJohn C. Maxwell, Les Parrott Ph.D.Thomas Nelson on Brilliance Audio / 2014 / Compact disc$9.99 Retail:
$14.99Save 33% ($5.00)Availability: In StockCBD Stock No: WW521890
Living By the Book: The Art and Science of Reading the Bible - eBookHoward G. Hendricks, William D. HendricksMoody Publishing / 2007 / ePub$8.39 Retail:5 Stars Out Of 5 30 Reviews
$14.24Save 41% ($5.85)Availability: In StockCBD Stock No: WW10403EB