In the Beginning God: A Fresh Look at the Case for Original Monotheism  -     By: Winfried Corduan
Buy Item $14.49 Retail: $19.99 Save 28% ($5.50) Add To Cart


Add To Wishlist
Buy eBook Begin reading in seconds $0.99 eBook Details

In the Beginning God: A Fresh Look at the Case for Original Monotheism

B&H Academic / 2013 / Paperback

$14.49 (CBD Price)
|
Retail: $19.99
|
Save 28% ($5.50)
Availability: In Stock
CBD Stock No: WW447783

Current Promotions
  • Other Formats (2)
  • Others Also Purchased (15)
Other Formats (2)
Description
Availability
Price
Add
Include
  1. In Stock
    $0.99
    Retail: $9.99
    Add To Cart
    0
    $0.99
  2. In Stock
    $14.49
    Retail: $19.99
    Add To Cart
    $14.49
Others Also Purchased (15)

Product Description

Christians believe religion began when God created human beings and revealed himself to them. But is there sufficient evidence for this belief?

In the nineteenth-century academic world, a story debate took shape over the origin of religion. A dominant view emerged that religion began with animism-the veneration of spirits-and only later evolved into higher forms, from polytheism to monotheism.

Yet, on the basis of discoveries made throughout the world, some scholars challenged the prevailing view. Andrew Lang and Wilhelm Schmidt contended that there are as many cultures on the lowest level of material development that orginated as monotheistic, acknowledging the existence of one supreme god who created the world and holds people accountable for living morally upright lives.

The debate wore on, and Schmidt, a member of a Catholic order and a priest, was accused (without evidence) of letting his faith interpret the facts. By the mid-twentieth century a silent consensus formed among scholars not to discuss the origin and evolution any further. The work of Lang and Schmidt has since been largely ignored.

However, the evidence on which these scholars based their conclusion is still there, and the case for an original monotheism still stands. In the Beginning God educates Christians about the debate--the facts that were accepted and those that were ignored--and how one can put this knowledge to use in making a case for the truth of Christianity.

Product Information

Format: Paperback
Number of Pages: 400
Vendor: B&H Academic
Publication Date: 2013
Dimensions: 9.00 X 6.00 X 1.03 (inches)
ISBN: 0805447784
ISBN-13: 9780805447781
Availability: In Stock

Other Customers Also Purchased

  1. Can You Believe It's True?: Christian Apologetics in a Modern and Postmodern Era
    Can You Believe It's True?: Christian Apologetics in a Modern and Postmodern Era
    John S. Feinberg
    Crossway / 2013 / Hardcover
    $26.99 Retail: $40.00 Save 33% ($13.01)
    4 Stars Out Of 5 1 Reviews
    Availability: In Stock
    CBD Stock No: WW539008
  2. Classical Apologetics
    Classical Apologetics
    R.C. Sproul
    Zondervan / 1984 / Trade Paperback
    $18.99 Retail: $25.99 Save 27% ($7.00)
    5 Stars Out Of 5 1 Reviews
    Availability: In Stock
    CBD Stock No: WW0449510
  3. No Doubt About It: The Case for Christianity
    No Doubt About It: The Case for Christianity
    Winfried Corduan
    B&H Books / 1997 / Trade Paperback
    $14.99 Retail: $19.99 Save 25% ($5.00)
    4 Stars Out Of 5 1 Reviews
    Availability: In Stock
    CBD Stock No: WW16471
  4. The New Evidence That Demands a Verdict
    The New Evidence That Demands a Verdict
    Josh McDowell
    Thomas Nelson / 1999 / Hardcover
    $16.99 Retail: $29.99 Save 43% ($13.00)
    4.5 Stars Out Of 5 28 Reviews
    Availability: In Stock
    CBD Stock No: WW42199

Related Products

  1. Five Views on Apologetics
    Five Views on Apologetics
    Steven B. Cowan, ed.
    Zondervan / 2000 / Trade Paperback
    $17.99 Retail: $24.99 Save 28% ($7.00)
    5 Stars Out Of 5 1 Reviews
    Availability: In Stock
    CBD Stock No: WW24764
  2. No Doubt About It: The Case for Christianity
    No Doubt About It: The Case for Christianity
    Winfried Corduan
    B&H Books / 1997 / Trade Paperback
    $14.99 Retail: $19.99 Save 25% ($5.00)
    4 Stars Out Of 5 1 Reviews
    Availability: In Stock
    CBD Stock No: WW16471
  3. The New Evidence That Demands a Verdict
    The New Evidence That Demands a Verdict
    Josh McDowell
    Thomas Nelson / 1999 / Hardcover
    $16.99 Retail: $29.99 Save 43% ($13.00)
    4.5 Stars Out Of 5 28 Reviews
    Availability: In Stock
    CBD Stock No: WW42199
  4. Classical Apologetics
    Classical Apologetics
    R.C. Sproul
    Zondervan / 1984 / Trade Paperback
    $18.99 Retail: $25.99 Save 27% ($7.00)
    5 Stars Out Of 5 1 Reviews
    Availability: In Stock
    CBD Stock No: WW0449510

Publisher's Description

 Christians believe that religion began when God created human beings and revealed himself to them. But is there scholarly evidence for this belief?

In the nineteenth century academic world a stormy debate took shape over the origin of religion. Scholars explored the ancient languages of mythology and then considered evolutionary anthropology. A dominant view emerged that religion began with animism -- the reverent honoring of spirits -- and from there evolved into higher forms, from polytheism on to monotheism.

However, scholars Andrew Lang and Wilhem Schmidt contended there were cultures throughout the world -- pygmy people in Africa and Asia, certain Australian Aboriginal groups and Native American tribes -- that originated as monotheistic, acknowledging the existence of one supreme God who created the world and holds people accountable for living morally upright lives.

The debate wore on, and Schmidt, a member of the Catholic order and a priest, was accused (without evidence) of letting his faith interpret the facts. By the mid-twentieth century a silent consensus formed among scholars not to discuss the origin and evolution of religion any further. The discoveries of Lang and Schmidt have since been largely ignored.

However, the evidence on which these scholars based their conclusion of monotheism is still out there. In the Beginning God attempts to educate Christians about the debate on this topic, the facts that were accepted and those that were ignored, and the use to which Christians can put all of this material in making a case for the truth of Christianity.

Author Bio

 Winfried Corduan (Ph.D., Rice University) is professor emeritus of Philosophy and Religion at Taylor University in Upland, Indiana.

Product Reviews

5 Stars Out Of 5
5 out of 5
(1)
(0)
(0)
(0)
(0)
Quality:
5 out Of 5
(5 out of 5)
Value:
5 out Of 5
(5 out of 5)
Meets Expectations:
5 out Of 5
(5 out of 5)
100%
of customers would recommend this product to a friend.
SORT BY:
SEE:
Displaying items 1-1 of 1
Page 1 of 1
  1. Becancour, QC
    Age: 25-34
    Gender: male
    5 Stars Out Of 5
    A REVIEW OF CORDUAN’S "IN THE BEGINNING GOD"
    May 5, 2014
    David
    Becancour, QC
    Age: 25-34
    Gender: male
    Quality: 5
    Value: 5
    Meets Expectations: 5
    In the Beginning God: A Fresh Look at the Case for Original Monotheism. By Winfried Corduan. Nashville, TN: B&H Academic, 2013. 368 pp. $19.99. ISBN 978-0-8054-4778-1.

    The idea that human religions developed, progressively, from some form of animism or polytheism into the predominant theistic religions has been the predominant view of historians and historians of religion for some time now. Evolutionary theory is applied to the development of human society and religion, and, in this way, we are told that humankind evolved from the least complicated religious views to the most complicated and developed religious views. Though the evolution of religion has been a predominant view, there have also been those who have proposed that, on the contrary, the original religion of mankind was Monotheism, and that this Monotheism was eventually corrupted, degrading into the various polytheism and animistic religions. In his recent book, "In the Beginning God", Winfried Corduan, a well-known expert in the study of Religions, argues that the theory of an original Monotheism merits a second chance, especially since it has never really been refuted; it was just put to the side by rhetorically powerful, but philosophically unsound, critiques. In this review we will begin by noting the purpose of the book. We will then give an overview of the content. This will be followed by our opinion concerning the relative worth of this book.

    The purpose of this book is to explain the genesis of the theory of original monotheism, its reception by those scholars who were researching the history of religion, and to contend that this theory, which has never been properly refuted, seems to be even more valid today, then it was when it was originally proposed. The book is written so that people who are unfamiliar with the study of the history of religion can understand what is at stake, and follow the discussion. However, the book will be of great interest to those who are currently involved in researching the history of religion.

    The book is presented almost like a history of the history of religions. The book advances by explaining each step in turn. The reader, in chapter 1, is introduced to the important questions that are asked by those who engage in the history of religion, as well as the terms that are used by this domain of research. Chapter 2 considers the contributions of Max Muller to the study of human religions, which developed out of his work concerning the Indo-European Languages. Muller proposed that much of Mythology came about through a confusion of and literal application of poetic language. We are introduced to his theory, his method, and the general application of his method to Sanskrit. We are then presented with Andrew Lang's critique of Muller. In chapter 3 we are introduced to E. B. Tylor, who is used as the primary representative of a Darwinian evolutionary theory concerning the development of human religions. Corduan begins by presenting a number of questionable assumptions that Tylor (and others) uncritically accepted. We are then introduced to a number of scholars who engaged in this debate, including Adolphe Pictet (who proposed original monotheism), and some of his critics: John Muir, Otto Pfleiderer and Edmond Scherer. These sections are used as a prelude to an examination of Tylor's work, which is explained and critiqued in the rest of the chapter. This chapter contains an interesting excursus concerning the development of a Darwinian history of socio-religious development. In chapter 4 Corduan returns to Lang, mentioned in chapter 2, in order to take a look at Lang's rejection of his professors', E. B. Tylor, theories, and his proposal of the possibility of an original monotheism. Lang's work centered around the aboriginals of Australia, and Corduan takes the time to explain the important elements of Lang's research and theories. Corduan also notes, as this chapter advances, the names and work of a number of prominent scholars whose research helped Lang. In chapter 5 Corduan continues his explanation of Andrew Lang's research, and introduces the reader to the various responses to Lang's theory. Corduan also takes the time to point the errors in Lang's research, but, even more importantly, the errors in the critiques of Lang's research. This chapter also explains the basic social structure of the Australian aboriginal groups (especially Totemism). The reader is left with the impression that the critiques of Lang's theories did not actually affect the overall theory.

    In chapter 6 we are introduced to Wilhelm Schmidt and Fritz Graebner. These scholars developed the Cultural-historical method of Ethnology, and in chapter 6 Corduan explains the important elements of their method, discusses elements which contribute to cultural migrations, and considers the elements that allow us to notice the possibility of interaction between cultures. In chapter 7 Corduan explains the results of the cultural-historical method. In this chapter Corduan considers a number of aboriginal groups in North America and shows how the cultural-historical method, when applied to these groups in North America, is able to give testable and falsifiable results (which, however, seem to be confirmed by the work of ethnologists and anthropologists). In chapter 8 Corduan considers the reception of Schmidt's work by noting how other scholars interacted with it. Corduan explains the most important critiques, and notes how none of them affect the overall method, but, rather, help to refine the results; rendering the method even more useful. One is left with the notion that most of the people who actually interacted with Schmidt and Graebner never even took the time to read and study their theory.

    In chapter 9 Corduan explains the theories of Mircea Eliade, Rudolf Otto and Émile Durkheim, showing how, rather than engage the question of the historical origin of human religions, these scholars preferred to remove all question of historicity, and concentrate on the psychological or phenomenological origins of religion. These authors created confusion by using the term "origin" in a psychological and non-historical (temporal) manner. Corduan takes the time to critique their views. In chapter 10 Corduan, rather than concentrating on those cultures that seem to be the most primitive (meaning closest to the original human culture), turns to the cultures of the great civilizations (Egypt, China, etc.). He seeks to discover whether it is possible, or not, to find, at the base of these polytheistic religions, a core of monotheism. Corduan does not make any absolute claims, but argues, providing evidence as needed, that there does indeed seem to be a monotheistic core in these religions. The concluding chapter is an overview of what has been discovered, a discussion of the utility of these discoveries for Christian Apologetics, as well as a caution concerning the use of these conclusions.

    Winfried Corduan presents a compelling case for the claim that the theory of original monotheism must be put back on the table. In fact, he presents a convincing argument that the theory of original monotheism was never removed from the table, just ignored by those who claimed to be working in that domain. As a relative beginner in this domain of research I found this book extremely interesting. The arguments presented by Corduan were well presented, and the evidence was easy to understand. I would have suspected that this type of book would have been difficult to follow, as I am unfamiliar with the history of this domain of research, but, the opposite was, in fact, the case. Corduan takes the time to explain the terms properly, to outline the arguments, and to introduce the important people who worked in this area of research. Corduan has presented the theory in an easy to understand and coherent manner. This book will hopefully stimulate renewed interest in the theory of original monotheism, and will hopefully send many scholars back to workshop in order to truly give this theory a critical consideration. I highly recommend this book.
Displaying items 1-1 of 1
Page 1 of 1

Ask Christianbook

Back
×

Ask Christianbook

What would you like to know about this product? Please enter your name, your email and your question regarding the product in the fields below, and we'll answer you in the next 24-48 hours.

If you need immediate assistance regarding this product or any other, please call 1-800-CHRISTIAN to speak directly with a customer service representative.

Find Related Products

Author/Artist Review

Start A New Search