With reward money in hand, Kate, Anders, and Erik head to a stable to buy a horse for Kate. A beautiful black stallion is for sale, but she discovers she can buy two poorly cared for horses for the price of one, and Kate strikes a deal. While riding home with Windsong and Breeza, Kate and Erik are startled when someone tries to grab Windsong's bridle. Kate eludes the would-be thief, but she's frightened. Who would want to steal a scruffy, underfed horse? When Windsong's lead rope is deliberately untied and the horse disappears, Kate becomes convinced her horse must be more valuable than she first believed. But Kate is also sure she's made a terrible mistake. Can she ever know the love of God again?
When someone tries to steal one of Kate's new horses, the Nordstrom family is shaken. But the real trauma comes when the barn is set on fire and the horse disappears. In a surprise ending, Kate finds her horse and discovers her future is going to be more exciting than she had expected.